This man is a sinner, therefore he is a .....

[Ahmed]

...Jahannumi?
Okay so this is a question I want to ask everybody. How does Islam view naming a muslim and saying that this person is going to hell?
Yeah I mean specifically pointing to someone and saying that person is jahannumi?

I specifaically want to know whether it is just discouraged or is it forbidden?
Will it be considered a sin for a muslim to say such a thing about another? Or just wrong but not a sin?

Thanks.

[Changez_like]

It is discouraged to say non-Muslims (especially alive) as 'kafir'... and I'm sure that it is "forbidden" to regard a Muslim as "jahannumi" because being human we don't know actually what will happen to him/her after (s)he dies, also we don't know in what condition he dies... bottomline we can't regard anyone as "jannati" or "jahannumi" it is ONLY ALLAH to decide.

------------------
We oughta be Changez like, don't we?

[Ahmed]

Anyone else...??