OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

[Ali_Syed]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

Now this is one big conspiracy theory.

Saudis cannot dare to keep a person alive which US wants dead.. and here we arent talking about some random person, its someone for which US was not shy to throw bundles of currency from top as they did in tribal areas in 2002.

Besides US politics doesnt work this way that Obama can win the mainstream presidential campaign on OBL's name.

the version that the U.S. Has come up with seems to be a fable at best. The version that they have thrown up is no different than the lies which the propagated for justifying Iraq war. The whole world believes only one version (the U.S. One) who can dare propagate an alternate version of the events surrounding matters like these?

[Anwer Pasha]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

Please don't be shy , tell us the name of the traitor who informed US and received the money otherwise let me say that you all are same

[Ali_Syed]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

When the operation took place some news came out that Pakistani intelligence officials has asked the people of the surrounding areas to stay indoors and the electricity was turned off. This was hushed up later...

The fact remains that obl was of no utility to anyone when he was killed. Pakistani army would have preferred to get his killing attributed to a drone strike. With the eventual unravelling of events the generals considered it prudent to take the blame of incompetence as compared to be a party to the alqaeda or the U.S.

[Anwer Pasha]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

When the operation took place some news came out that Pakistani intelligence officials has asked the people of the surrounding areas to stay indoors and the electricity was turned off. This was hushed up later...
The fact remains that obl was of no utility to anyone when he was killed. Pakistani army would have preferred to get his killing attributed to a drone strike. With the eventual unravelling of events the generals considered it prudent to take the blame of incompetence as compared to be a party to the alqaeda or the U.S.

US is successful because its CIA is run by qualified and leaned civilian , no concern with their soldiers . we are slaves of 12 pass

[ajazali]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

When the operation took place some news came out that Pakistani intelligence officials has asked the people of the surrounding areas to stay indoors and the electricity was turned off. This was hushed up later...

The fact remains that obl was of no utility to anyone when he was killed. Pakistani army would have preferred to get his killing attributed to a drone strike. With the eventual unravelling of events the generals considered it prudent to take the blame of incompetence as compared to be a party to the alqaeda or the U.S.

I dont think that is true. If it had happened, independent media sources must have extracted this truth from the locality where operation was conducted. Also, you cant force people to not to spread this truth that they were told to stay at home in the time of operation.
If they wanted people stay inside they would have used some other tactics instead of coming in-front of people and delivering message directly.

[Anwer Pasha]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

I dont think that is true. If it had happened, independent media sources must have extracted this truth from the locality where operation was conducted. Also, you cant force people to not to spread this truth that they were told to stay at home in the time of operation.
If they wanted people stay inside they would have used some other tactics instead of coming in-front of people and delivering message directly.

It is quite true , These people remain active after this all and stopped every one to come close , so no civilian could come close .

[ajazali]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

It is quite true , These people remain active after this all and stopped every one to come close , so no civilian could come close .

Stopping people to come close to the site is one thing, asking people to stay inside is the other thing. But no independent source is found to verify that people of locality were forced to stay away or stay at home.

[Anwer Pasha]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

Stopping people to come close to the site is one thing, asking people to stay inside is the other thing. But no independent source is found to verify that people of locality were forced to stay away or stay at home.

Perhaps you have not been reading Urdu news , Urdu papers were telling these all stories .

[ajazali]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

Perhaps you have not been reading Urdu news , Urdu papers were telling these all stories .

any reference?

[Anwer Pasha]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

ISPR and others who are very fond of remaining in news and their photos always .....
Silent over big story

[Anwer Pasha]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

any reference?

I have been posting those days about OBL threads , not remember exactly
Urdu search is difficult , some time impossible of being in image shape , just like the article I posted in this thread , You will have to trust my old brain

[Ali_Syed]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

any reference?

I read it in some newspapers the next day of the operation.

[Ali_Syed]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

Please don't be shy , tell us the name of the traitor who informed US and received the money otherwise let me say that you all are same

In 2006 Musharraf was at the helm of affairs, in 2010 it was kayani and pasha. I'd be interested to know about the guy who leaked the information. As per the news article he is now directly working for the CIA these days.

[Ali_Syed]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

Three years old news...

https://nadeemmalik.wordpress.com/20...shaukat-qadir/

from 2011...the U.S. Choppers flew from tarbela in Pakistan and not from Afghanistan as we have been told.

http://tribune.com.pk/story/160560/the-operation-what-exactly-happened-in-abbottabad/

[Moonstar201]

Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh

Perhaps you have not been reading Urdu news , Urdu papers were telling these all stories .

this is correct. Remember the time of this attack and many interviews of locals. they mentioned it clearly. Even they were so afraid at that time to talk to media