Pakistani newspaper interviews Bal Thackrey

[mohabbat]

http://www.jang.com.pk/thenews/feb20...main/main2.htm

Thackeray wants Pakistan, India to 'live and let live'

By Nusrat Javeed

MUMBAI: Defying his venom-spitting reputation, Shiv Sena chief Bal Thackeray has proposed a "live and let live" policy to Pakistan. "Our problems can only be addressed if the two countries realise that "enough is enough and time has come to live and let live," Thackeray told at his high-security residence.

[chilli]

At one point in the interview Bal Thackeray says :


It's only the Muslims who relish the liberty of drumming the Muslim thoughts in India and get away with it. We have a newspaper with the name of "Muslim India," for example. Can a Hindu dare to print any publication with the name of "Hindu Pakistan" in your country?



I would like to hear from our Paki friends on this.........

[proudpakistani]

Chilli.
Actually we have a bimonthly paper in Pakistan called Pakistani Hindu with internet link. (http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Delphi/7295/)




------------------
unity, faith, discipline

[Mr Xtreme]

Pakistani Hindus have their own online magazine as well.

[chilli]

Hold it....

Pakistani Hindu is not the same as "Hindu Pakistan"(which Thackeray was referring to).

Xtreme , online materials don't mean too much, do they ?

[rvikz]

pakistani hindus are born there lived there for thousands of years even before islam and hinduism same way indian muslim.just because of religen both groups have beccame alienated
in their own countries. somehow chinese and japanese escaped this evil situation

[Rani]

ProudPakistani

Originally posted by proudpakistani:
Chilli.
Actually we have a bimonthly paper in Pakistan called Pakistani Hindu with internet link. (http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Delphi/7295/)

That is not a newspaper that is an outdated bulltien board. Date on newpaper is Mid April, 2000 - Mid June, 2000. Bal Tackeray is right minorities have no rights in Pakistan. The same people who don't want to give rights to anybody demand equal rights from others.

Minority rights are not big issue in Pakistan because it has almost no minorities.



[This message has been edited by Rani (edited February 16, 2001).]

[PureLand]

Rani says

That is not a newspaper that is an outdated bulltien board. Date on newpaper is Mid April, 2000 - Mid June, 2000. Bal Tackeray is right minorities have no rights in Pakistan. The same people who don't want to give rights to anybody demand equal rights from others.

Minority rights are not big issue in Pakistan because it has almost no minorities.

If you think Pakistan has no minorities,
then what are you crying about?

Whatever minorities we have, they're living
with peace in Pakistan and they love their
country. Since they've giving all the
rights, there is no need for Hindu or
chiristian Pakistan


[This message has been edited by PureLand (edited February 16, 2001).]

[Rani]

Originally posted by PureLand:
Rani says
If you think Pakistan has no minorities,
then what are you crying about?

Whatever minorities we have, they're living
with peace in Pakistan and they love their
country. Since they've giving all the
rights, there is no need for Hindu or
chiristian Pakistan


[This message has been edited by PureLand (edited February 16, 2001).]

It is amusing that u r preaching us when you have practiced ethinic cleaning and chased all minorities away.

Bal Thakeray is saying that in India muslims get all the freedom which they never will give to non-muslim in their countries. In this day age of media of media scrutiny every thing that goes on comes out in open. There may be lag in understanding how particular regime or religious group works, but eventally it is there for everybody to see. Indians are learning very fast how muslim treat non-muslims.

Do onto others as u want them do to u, is a good philosphy to follow.



[This message has been edited by Rani (edited February 16, 2001).]

[Rani]

Main Munna Khan,

Toleration is not one way street. You want others to be tolerant and accepting of you become tolerant and accepting of others.

As for your twisted history no Hindu and Sikh moved here lock stock and barrel they were chased out.

Muslims r literate and drain to the society because their mullahs don't want them to be educated they r scared that they wouldn't be able to control them.

I love it, when u jump and down and teach us morality while u have no concept of acceptance and justice. I love your's and your buddies selective morality; India should be secular but Pakistan can be relgious theocracy , Hindutava is sooo bad but muslim league, Jamaat and other such organisations are very good.

Good luck nobody is buying your selective morality anymore.

[kabir]

well guys dont read too much into the interview of this maniac called bal thackray
bal thackray is nothing but a two faced snake
it is the same bal thacrya who had asked the hindus to open the shakars third eye (destruction ) during the anti muslim riots ofbombay in 1992
it is the same bal thackray who ones called indian muslims a cancer of india
it is the same bal thackray who again during the 1992 riots had in a interview to cnn news reporter said "we will throw out the muslims from india"
it is the same bal thackray who had openly stated in zee tv that it was his shiv sena which was responsilbe for the shadat of babri masjid.
it is the same bal thackray who said hritik roshan is the hindu answer to khans
bal thackray is a scorpion he hates muslim.
so its not important what he said in an interview to pak daily
i can quote hundred of his statements which shows his hatred for muslims.

[Akif]

So Bal Thackeray is saying muslims have 'more rights' in india...but is he right?

Remember Babri masjid, and the x number of other masjids demolished by hindus, or claimed by the shiv sena as the birth sites of x number of gods?
And most of all, remember Kashmir?

Merely having a newspaper does not prove anything. Newspapers are just that....papers. Anyone can take out a newspaper anywhere, as long as one has an audience. In Pakistan there are not that many hindus, hence a hindu paper would not command an audience. Hence it would make no sense to take one out. In india there are 150 mil+ muslims, so yes, a muslim paper would have a handsome circulation.

India wont even grant passports to APHC members, solely because they are muslims. The argument that muslims have more rights in india than hindus in Pakistan is flimsy.

[ZZ]

Originally posted by Akif:


Remember Babri masjid, and the x number of other masjids demolished by hindus, or claimed by the shiv sena as the birth sites of x number of gods?

which 'x' other masjids and where did u get this info.

[Azad Munna]

Originally posted by Rani:
Main Munna Khan,

Toleration is not one way street. You want others to be tolerant and accepting of you become tolerant and accepting of others.

As for your twisted history no Hindu and Sikh moved here lock stock and barrel they were chased out.

Muslims r literate and drain to the society because their mullahs don't want them to be educated they r scared that they wouldn't be able to control them.

I love it, when u jump and down and teach us morality while u have no concept of acceptance and justice. I love your's and your buddies selective morality; India should be secular but Pakistan can be relgious theocracy , Hindutava is sooo bad but muslim league, Jamaat and other such organisations are very good.

Good luck nobody is buying your selective morality anymore.

Rani ,
I or indian muslims DID NOT make indian constitution or secularism or democaracy.That is the founding fathers declared policy.I tell you ,let Indian people do whatever they want to do ,they have right like Pakistan do whatever it wants.Paskistan does what it does is because it is 99% muslim .Do you thin k if India becomes HINDU PAKISTAN ,you will as sikh exist as sikh.Yes muslims will suffer with sikh ,parsi,christian,jews & other minoreties of india.Let see India govt, do that.India is composed multicultural NOT HOMOGENOUS like PAKISTAN,so stop comparing apple & oranges.


"I love it, when u jump and down and teach us morality while u have no
concept of acceptance and justice. I love your's and your buddies
selective morality; India should be secular but Pakistan can be relgious
theocracy , Hindutava is sooo bad but muslim league, Jamaat and other
such organisations are very good.

Good luck nobody is buying your selective morality anymore."RANI

Atleast im not preaching you anything ,just telling you have NO oTHER option but to be secular democratic ,if you wont it is incapable of existing with so much diversity.India is secular not because it wanted to be but it is muticultural inherently .India is not tolerent or magnaminous to muslims as an invited guest but because they have been there for 1200 yrs.Muslim didnt come AFTER secularism but secularism is there because of so many prexisting muslims sikhs jains christians parsi,jews,arya samaj brahmo samaj anand marg,bahai,tribals nagas,bodo,....

------------------


*Negahe Marde Momin Se Badal Jate Hai Taqdeeren*

[Azad Munna]

Originally posted by ZZ:
which 'x' other masjids and where did u get this info.

There is a mosque ,which came to attention only b/c of Quake,locked by archelogical historical dept. govt.of india which was opened briefly out of fear of some hindu who cleaned it for muslims to pray for mercy from god for few days before it has been locked back by vhp & RSS operatives in Ahmedabad!
There are inneumerable mosques abandoned in Calcutta Bengal & where ever there was mass shifting of population on religous line.I dont think indian hindu did anything to it but just as in Pakistan due to abandment of mandir & lack of attendees ,mandir are in shabby condition just as some areas mosques are also in shabby condition.

------------------


*Negahe Marde Momin Se Badal Jate Hai Taqdeeren*