Two Nation Theory - A Pakistani's view

[Andhra]

http://www.dawn.com/weekly/mazdak/mazdak.htm

Go to this URL and see what Mazdak has to say about two nation theory.
Looks like he is saying what Indians have been saying all along

[Musalman]

That is his opinion, Pakistan is a reality, then our slogun was "TUT KAY RAHY GA HINDUATAN, BAN KAY RAHY GA PAKISTAN" So by the will of ALLAH (SWT) Pakistan came into being. Our current slogen is " KASHMIR HAMARA HAY", so Inshallah in time every body will here the news of Kashmir joining the Islamic Ummah. We are one people, all Muslims from east to west and from north to south, ONE UMMAH. We not only want Kashmir we also want full rights be given to our Muslim brothers and sisters living in India, or else............

[Andhra]

Small correction Pakistan WAS a reality.
Because at the time of partition Pakistan was the country that calls itself Pakistan now and Bangladesh.
Now in 1971 if Bengalis wanted to call their new country Pakistan, India would have certainly agreed to it.
Enjoy life and don't get worked up.
The article was speaking the truth.

[Musalman]

Article is crap, we respect our elders, but his generation is almost gone, you wait when its time for us to call the shots, we have conquered you before we will conquer you again. Give it up, resistance is futile !!

[This message has been edited by Musalman (edited November 07, 2000).]

[Rani]

we have conquered you before we will conquer you again. Give it up, resistance is futile !!

You were also conquered by taking on the religion of conquerer you don't become one of them.

[The Watcher]

Rani, Islam is a religion which does not see race or color or ethnic background. It just molds the person practicing it into its colors. Unlike any other religion, so it might be hard for you to understand this, because "other" religions do not have this concept!

------------------
*V~V~V*He came, He saw, He conquered*V~V~V*

[hk]

Originally posted by Rani:
You were also conquered by taking on the religion of conquerer you don't become one of them.

you dont know what you're talking about. Islam doesnt BELONG to anyone......we're Muslims by choice (neither do we want to become one of the conquerers)....
As it says in the Holy Quran:
"There is no compulsion in religion"

Stick to the topic, dont bring Islam into this.

[Rani]

HK,

How about telling your friend Musalman to stick to the topic. Insulting others will only get you insulted back.

[rvikz]

Muslim Bengali had far more in common with a Hindu from Calcutta than a
Punjabi Muslim, while a Pushtun from Durra is much closer culturally and
ethnically to his cousin in Jalalabad in Afghanistan than he is to a
Muslim in Chittagong. These very real differences were glossed over by
the over-simplifications on which the Two-National Theory is based.

[sabah]

Could we continue in the other thread on this issue? Altaf Hussain’s yada yada thread that is?

Musalman, hmmm before wasting your time on explaining what Mazdak has written, perhaps you’d like to check what else he says about Pakistan

[sabah]

Oye and Andhra Welcome back janab